I’d like to throw in my 2 cents in regard to the battle between acoustic and electronic drums. I have almost 20 years experience with both of them so I consider myself qualified to make the following assessment. Keep in mind this is merely my own opinion.
It is not like comparing apples to apples, more like comparing a fresh, ripe fruit basket to a fruit cake. Not the best analogy, but it’ll do. The fruit cake or acoustic
drum set is a one trick pony so to speak. It definitely does sound amazing when played alone, in a band situation, amplified in a live bands performance type scenario and in the studio, there is no doubt about that. But, and this might get long, that is the one sound you will get, forever. Based on the number of plies the shell has, the shell composition, (whether it be Basswood, Birch, Maple, or a hybrid of some sort) not to mention the tuning of the
head and head type, are the few tone determining factors. Granted, you can get quite a few sounds out of a standard acoustic drum set by simply changing these variables, but still not nearly the arsenal of sounds available to the player when using an
electronic set. I’ll break it down for ya. Tune your
toms tighter on the batter side and tighter on the resonant side and you have more of a jazz sound to them. Same goes for the
kick drum, tighten it up a bit on the batter side and remove some head dampening, you will get a more distinctive jazz sound, which has a lot more throat and mid-range head resonance to it. The
snare drum is no exception, loosen the tension rods a bit on the batter and resonant head as well as the actual snare wires and you get a mellower, jazzier sound. Now, with all that said, think about how much time it would take to make your “Rock Tuned” drum set sound like a “Jazz” kit. Not your typical 15-20 minute drum tuning tweak-up, no, it will literally take you more like 1-2 hours and possibly more if you are as picky as I am regarding drum sound. It may even take a major drum head replacement. Just something to think about.
Enter the Electronic Drum Set! Now, if I used an electronic drum set or even a standard drum set with dampened heads and a full trigger setup triggering a decent sound module, I can play live gigs and completely change the sound of my kit with merely the turn of a knob. I know what you’re thinking, it really is NOT that easy, and you are correct, it isn’t that easy. But once you go through some initial setup with your
module to find the sound you want, it becomes that easy. Here is a little background about myself. I am the type of drummer that has a vision or an ideal sound in mind and I will tweak the settings for as long as I have to until they are right and sit well in the mix of whatever band I am tailoring my drum sound to fit. An example of a “decent” drum module would be the
Roland TD12. It has an incredible library of sounds ready to be sculpted to your taste and Roland makes it very simple to modify to your liking. Select the drum you want to edit, and start tweaking. You can change the shell material, thickness, depth, diameter, as well as tune the heads by changing the tension and add or remove effects or dynamics processors. Very intuitive. In the case of a drummer wanting to actually play the electronic set in a live situation… that is easily done too since they are typically quite compact and portable. I do hear numerous folks that have played electronics and/or own them and I hear a common issue, the feeling is not there. It does not feel like an acoustic drum set and all I can say to that is, “Darn right, it isn’t an acoustic drum set!” It is a drawback to even myself but that is exactly why I am the type of player to add
triggers to my acoustic set. I want the feel and rebound of acoustic drums with the sound versatility of an electronic kit but not for all applications. I will still use my electronic setup for rehearsal rather than my full acoustic drum set that would need to be mic’d in order to have a nice mix sent to my
in-ear monitors, the electronics just make that aspect and many others so much easier. So there you have it. Any comments?
-Ryan
Labels: acoustic, acoustic drums, drum head, drum module, drum set, Drum Triggers, drums, Electronic drums, In-Ear Monitors, kick drum, music, Roland TD12, snare drum, tom tom drum